Infidelity is one of the most emotionally devastating events in any romantic relationship. It challenges the foundation of trust, creates a breach of loyalty, and often leaves both partners feeling confused and hurt. A common adage associated with infidelity is the phrase, “Once a cheater, always a cheater.” But is this statement fair, or is it an oversimplification of human behavior?

Cheating is a multifaceted issue that doesn’t always stem from malicious intent. Many couples therapists believe that infidelity can be influenced by a variety of personal, relational, and situational factors. In this article, we’ll unpack expert opinions, psychological theories, and actionable insights to determine whether a single act of betrayal signifies a permanent behavioral pattern or an opportunity for growth.

What Couples Therapists Say About Infidelity

1. Understanding the Root Causes

Many couples therapists agree that infidelity is often a symptom of deeper, unaddressed issues. The reasons for cheating can vary greatly between individuals and relationships, but some of the most common causes include:

• Emotional Disconnection: A lack of intimacy, communication, or understanding can lead one partner to seek emotional fulfillment outside the relationship.
• Personal Insecurity: Low self-esteem or a desire for external validation may push someone to cheat.
• Relational Dissatisfaction: If needs (emotional, physical, or otherwise) go unmet, infidelity might seem like a solution.

According to Dr. Shirley Glass, author of Not “Just Friends,” cheating is less about sex and more about secrecy, emotional intimacy, and betrayal. Addressing these underlying factors is essential for healing.

2. Differentiating Between Types of Infidelity

Therapists often categorize infidelity into two main types:

• Emotional Infidelity: Forming a deep emotional connection with someone outside the relationship, which can be just as damaging as physical cheating.
• Physical Infidelity: Engaging in sexual or physical acts with another person.

Understanding the type of betrayal can help couples navigate the healing process more effectively. For example, emotional cheating might require reconnecting on a deeper level, while physical infidelity might demand rebuilding trust.

3. Infidelity Does Not Always Define Character

Many therapists emphasize that infidelity doesn’t always reflect a person’s character. While chronic cheaters may display traits like narcissism or a lack of empathy, one-time offenders often feel deep remorse and a genuine desire to make amends.

READ MORE: Building Wealth vs. Building Debt: 11 Smart Strategies the Wealthy Use to Thrive Financially

In cases of isolated incidents, therapists like Dr. Harriet Lerner suggest that individuals can change if they acknowledge their mistakes and commit to self-improvement. “Infidelity isn’t a death sentence for a relationship,” she says. “It’s an opportunity to confront what’s broken.”

The Psychology Behind Cheating

1. Attachment Styles and Their Impact

Attachment theory provides a useful lens for understanding why some people cheat. A person’s attachment style, often formed in childhood, influences how they approach intimacy and conflict.

• Secure Attachment: Individuals with secure attachment styles are less likely to cheat, as they tend to value trust and emotional stability.
• Avoidant Attachment: People with avoidant tendencies may struggle with intimacy and seek independence through infidelity.
• Anxious Attachment: Those with anxious attachment styles may cheat out of fear of abandonment or a need for constant reassurance.

Therapists often explore these attachment styles to uncover patterns and develop healthier relational behaviors.

2. The Role of Opportunity and Temptation

Sometimes, cheating occurs not because of dissatisfaction but because of opportunity. Situations like traveling for work, alcohol-fueled encounters, or social media connections can lower inhibitions and lead to poor decisions.

Dr. Tammy Nelson, author of The New Monogamy, highlights the importance of situational awareness. “Healthy boundaries and self-discipline are crucial in preventing infidelity, especially in environments where temptation is high,” she explains.

3. The Brain and the Thrill of Cheating

Cheating can activate the brain’s reward system, releasing dopamine, the feel-good chemical associated with pleasure and excitement. This chemical response can make the act of infidelity feel thrilling, even addictive. However, this temporary high often leads to guilt, shame, and regret.

Can a Cheater Truly Change?

The idea that a person is forever defined by their mistakes is both limiting and pessimistic. Therapists generally agree that change is possible, but it requires effort, accountability, and introspection.

1. Factors That Influence Change

The likelihood of change depends on several factors:

• Self-Awareness: Does the individual recognize the reasons behind their behavior?
• Genuine Remorse: Are they willing to own up to their actions and express empathy for their partner?
• Commitment to Growth: Are they actively working to address the underlying issues through therapy, self-reflection, or education?

2. Signs of True Change

• Consistent honesty and transparency in communication.
• Willingness to undergo individual or couples therapy.
• Behavioral changes that reflect new priorities and values.

Therapists caution against relying on promises alone. Actions over time are the true indicators of transformation.

When Infidelity Becomes a Pattern

While some individuals are capable of change, others may repeat the same behaviors. Chronic infidelity can indicate deeper issues, such as:

• Commitment Phobia: A fear of settling down or losing independence.
• Narcissistic Tendencies: A lack of empathy and an inflated sense of entitlement.
• Addictive Behaviors: A compulsive need for the excitement or validation that comes with cheating.

In such cases, therapy can help, but it’s crucial for the faithful partner to establish boundaries and prioritize their own emotional well-being.

How Couples Can Heal After Infidelity

Healing after betrayal is a long and challenging process. However, with dedication and the right strategies, it’s possible for couples to rebuild their relationship.

1. Acknowledge the Pain

The first step is allowing both partners to express their feelings. The betrayed partner needs space to process their hurt, anger, and confusion, while the unfaithful partner must listen and validate these emotions. Suppressing or dismissing the pain only hinders recovery.

2. Seek Professional Help

Couples therapy provides a safe space to explore the reasons behind infidelity and develop a roadmap for healing. Therapists guide couples in addressing underlying issues, improving communication, and setting realistic expectations.

3. Focus on Transparency

Rebuilding trust requires complete honesty. This may involve sharing passwords, being open about schedules, or providing regular updates to reassure the betrayed partner.

4. Rediscover Intimacy

Infidelity often damages physical and emotional intimacy. Couples can rekindle their connection by spending quality time together, engaging in shared activities, and prioritizing physical affection.

5. Forgiveness as a Choice

Forgiveness doesn’t mean forgetting or condoning the betrayal. Instead, it’s about letting go of resentment to make space for healing. Forgiveness is a personal journey that takes time and effort.

Key Takeaways

• Infidelity is complex: It often reflects deeper personal or relational issues rather than inherent dishonesty.
• Cheating doesn’t define the future: With accountability, remorse, and effort, individuals can learn and grow beyond their mistakes.
• Healing is a collaborative process: Both partners must commit to open communication, trust-building, and professional support.
• Some patterns are hard to break: Chronic infidelity may signal deeper psychological challenges that require individual intervention.

Conclusion: What Do You Think?

Infidelity is never a simple issue. While some relationships emerge stronger after betrayal, others may find that the damage is irreparable. What matters most is how both partners choose to move forward.

Now, over to you!

• Have you experienced or witnessed a relationship that survived infidelity? What made it work—or fail?
• Do you believe in the idea that people can change, or do you think cheating is a dealbreaker?

Let’s create a safe space for dialogue. Share your thoughts, stories, and opinions in the comments below. Remember, your perspective might just help someone else navigating their own challenges.

No matter the outcome, the journey of healing and self-discovery after infidelity can lead to stronger relationships—whether with your partner or with yourself.